Hume's Thesis
All our ideas are derived from
impressions.
(Cf. Locke on "tabula rasa.")
Arguments for the thesis:
- 1. Analysis:
- "[W]hen we analyze our . . . ideas . . . we always find that they
resolve themselves into such simple ideas as were copied from a precedent
feeling or sentiment [i.e. an impression]." (P 158b)
Example: our idea of God
- 2. Defect of Organ:
- "If it happen, from a defect of the organ, that a man is not
suscepible of any species of sensation, we always find that he is as
little susceptible of the correspondent ideas." (P 159a)
Example: man born blind
Notice that argument (1) applies to complex ideas and argument (2)
to simple ideas.
Richard Lee,
rlee@comp.uark.edu,
last modified: 29 March 1999