Introduction to Philosophy: Overhead

Taylor's Deliberation Argument (IP3 377bf)

1. We can deliberate about whether we will do something.
2. If it is possible to know beforehand what we will do, then we cannot deliberate about whether we will do it.
3. If determinism is true, then it is possible to know beforehand what we will do.
4. Determinism is false. (1, 2, 3)

Richard Lee, rlee@uark.edu, last modified: 10 October 2004

	1.	We can deliberate about whether we will do something.
	2.	If it is possible to know beforehand what we will do, then we cannot deliberate about whether we will do it.
	3.	If determinism is true, then it is possible to know beforehand what we will do.
	4.	Determinism is false. (1, 2, 3)