1. | Intense heat = pain. | |
2. | For every x, if x cannot perceive, then x cannot have pain. | |
3. | Material substances cannot perceive. | |
4. | Material substances cannot have pain. (2,3) | |
5. | Material substances cannot have intense heat. (4,1) | |
6. | An external object is a material substance. | |
7. | External objects cannot have intense heat. (5,6) |
Premises in the text:
1. "But is not the most vehement and intense degree of heat a very great pain? / No one can deny it." (P 164a)
2. "And is any unperceiving thing capable of pain or pleasure? / No, certainly." (P 164a)
3. "Is your material substance a senseless being or a being endowed with sense and perception? / It is senseless, without doubt." (P 164a)
4. "It [material substance] cannot, therefore, be the subject of pain? / By no means." (P 164a)
5. "Nor, consequently, [can material substances be the subject] of the greatest heat perceived by sense ..." (P 164a)
6. "What shall we say then of your external object: is it a material substance or no? / It is a material substance with the sensible qualities inhering in it." (P 164b)
C. "How then can a great heat exist in [an external object] ...?" (P 164b)