Professional Deception
(Joseph Ellin)
"Ordinary morality is designed to protect people's total package
of interests, which, as interests, are considered equally worthy of
protection; but professional morality protects only those interests
for which the professional relationship exists. Professional morality
is thus spared the necessity of assigning weights to various interests in
order to balance them in case of conflict. Deception is thus not a
violation of professional morality, since professionals are not mandated
to protect the client's interest in having true beliefs, in not being
manipulated or in being treated with respect."
Example: Doctors and Patients
"A patient's interest in the truth . . . is exactly as relevant to the
doctor's professional concern as the patient's interest in friends or
enjoyable leisure: That is, all these interests are relevant to the
physician's responsibility only as they might affect the patient's
health."
"Since the interests which deception harms are not otherwise relevant to
the fiduciary medical context, there is no reason within that context to
prohibit deception."
Richard Lee,
rlee@comp.uark.edu,
last modified: 19 June 2000